The three promises to make right after you invest

 đź‘‹ Hi! This is Small Bets, a newsletter that unpacks the world of early-stage investing.

(Forwarded this? Join 93k+ startup enthusiasts by subscribing here.)

🍫 A snack for the road: Say hello to Hustle Commons and its new GM

This week we're excited to officially announce the launch of Hustle Commons and the promotion of Janel Spilker to GM of Hustle Commons - yay! Read the full article on what's changing and what's staying the same >>

đź“° Today's topic: The three promises to make right after you invest

Too many investors treat their initial investment as their main point of contact with a company. They’ll wire the money, say “let me know if you need anything,” and then they won’t be heard from again until something major happens (exit, down round, major partnership announcement, etc.).

This is a surefire way to never stand out as a VC. At Hustle Fund, we do something different. In our very first meeting with a new portfolio company after our investment, we walk through what we call our “social contract.”

It’s a list of promises between both parties. It’s not written down anywhere, and nobody signs it, but it shapes the whole relationship, and it’s how we set ourselves up to have a fruitful relationship with every company we invest in.

Promise one: blunt honesty, both ways

Our first promise is to give direct feedback, whether we love an idea or hate it. We ask the founder to assume the feedback comes from a good place, because we genuinely want them to succeed. And success in startups means being willing to have hard conversations.

We also ask our founders to hold us equally accountable. If we’re getting in the way or not doing what we said we’d do, we want them to feel comfortable telling us so directly. In our view, candid communication is pivotal for a successful partnership.

Promise two: assume things are going badly

Whenever we talk to our portfolio companies, we let them know that we’ll approach the conversation as if things are going badly with the business.

This isn’t a knock on our portfolio companies. It’s a hack that helps both parties feel more comfortable discussing difficult matters. As former founders ourselves, we understand that even when things seem okay, there are so many issues below the surface that feel existential. So instead of small talk and a highlight reel that only includes the good stuff, we want founders to feel comfortable telling us what’s keeping them up at night. Hence why we start every chat with the same question: what’s the biggest blocker right now, and how can we help?

Promise three: you have permission to lose our investment

We tell every founder we invest in that they have permission to lose our investment.

As longtime early-stage investors, we know that failure is part of the entrepreneurial journey. We don’t invest expecting failure, but we’re at peace with the possibility that the business might not work out. You literally have to be when you’re investing in early-stage companies. We know that losing other people’s money feels terrible, and we want to free our founders from having to carry that burden by letting them know it’s okay. As long as you were honest, worked hard on the problems, and gave it your best effort, we won’t hold it against you. Most of the time, a founder will learn from that failure, and we’ll be even more excited to invest in their next company.

Why these promises matter

This isn’t just about good vibes.

When founders feel safe, they’re more honest with us. That allows us to spot problems and identify progress much earlier than other investors. Sometimes, if we like what we’re seeing, we’ll offer to invest more before a round even comes together, without waiting for a lead or competing with a crowd.

We believe our approach also helps preserve relationships. Hustle Fund only follows on in about 20% of our portfolio investments, and we tell founders that up front. If we pass on a second check, we explain exactly why, so nobody is surprised. In one case, we skipped the follow-on because we doubted the founders could build a strong team, and we were wrong. The team they assembled turned out to be excellent, so we went back at the Series A, admitted our mistake, and paid a higher price to get in. Because the relationship was honest and the founders knew they could trust us, they gladly welcomed us back.

Use our approach in your own investing

You don’t need to be a fund partner to follow our approach. Consider the following tactics with your portfolio companies:

  • People often go into fight-or-flight mode when they’re surprised. So ask permission before giving tough feedback. Something like “I have some direct feedback, is it okay if I share it?”

  • Lead with your own honesty. If you talk openly about your own struggles, it often gives other people permission to do the same.

  • Make your check-ins easy to answer. Try sending a weekly or monthly text to founders saying something like: “Anything blocking you this week that I can help with? No need to respond.”

  • Deliver bad news with a smile, too; it’s a small thing, but it disarms people.

The cost of the social contract is one awkward conversation, and in return you get a founder who tells you the truth, and that’s worth more than any clause in the paperwork.

– Brian from Angel Squad

We're hiring: Financial Controller

Hustle Fund is looking for a hands-on Financial Controller to own our day-to-day accounting, from bank and card reconciliations through month-end close and financial statements for the management company and funds. You'll work with our CFO/COO, fund admins, auditors and tax preparers, and help build AI-assisted workflows that make our reporting faster.

Remote (US: CA, MD, NH, OR, TN only)

$135,000-$150,000 + benefits

Know someone great? Please forward this along.

Overheard in SF…probably

“We have a strategic partnership, meaning I got coffee with someone at Google once.”